A Reuters/Ispos poll Wednesday showed
that 63 percent of Americans felt “the use of torture against suspected
terrorists” was “often or sometimes justified.” The levels of support are
roughly equivalent to Nigeria, which is enduring a seven-year insurgency, and
Kenya which has been hit with a number of large-scale attacks by Al Shabaab in
recent years, Reuters noted.
But Jack Bauer does it.
"There’s no question now that national security and
terrorism are growing in salience in this political cycle," says Ken
Gude, a senior fellow with the national security team at the Center for
American Progress. "It’s incumbent upon our political leaders to not
engage in the kind of political rhetoric that drives a jittery population
toward policies like torture ... that only play right into the hands of our
enemies."
Of course that's what the liberals say.
The idea that useful information can be extracted by torture
has been debunked throughout history – from French torturers in the Renaissance
to Japanese torturers during World War II, Mr. Freeman notes. Post-9/11 America
has found the same thing, most experts agree.
Oh, then why do it?
While there is very little support for Mr. Trump's assertion
that "torture works" as an interrogation technique, torture really
has a different purpose, experts say: social control.
"Indeed, for the many governments around the world that
still routinely practice torture, it is seen as much as a tool for intimidation
as information-gathering," writes Colin Freeman in The Telegraph.
Maybe he is Hitler, or at least Saddam Hussein.
The non-liberals against torture:
- Former
Federal Bureau of Investigation interrogator Jack Cloonan, who was
directly involved in the questioning of some of the United States'
high-profile prisoners, told Foreign Policy it was a public misconception
that harsh interrogation tactics like waterboarding were an effective way
of extracting information. Instead, Mr. Cloonan said such techniques
strengthened the resolve of the terrorist groups to exact revenge on the
United States and were a great recruiting tool for young jihadis,
elevating those tortured to "mythical status."
- Malcolm
Nance, head of the Terrorism Asymmetrics Project and a veteran of Navy
intelligence, said Trump's reiterated call after Brussels to bring
back waterboarding was likely giving the Islamic State free propaganda
material. "Donald Trump right now is validating the cartoonish
view that they tell their operatives … that America is a racist nation,
xenophobic, anti-Muslim, and that that's why you must carry out terrorist
attacks against them," he told MSNBC.
- Michael
Hayden, the last head of the Central Intelligence Agency under the Bush
administration, who has previously defended interrogation tactics used
during that era, publicly explained why it would be illegal for US armed
forces to obey Trump’s call to use torture. General Hayden also said Trump
is already acting as a recruiter for so called Islamic State in a
television interview with Al Jazeera.
- A 2014
Senate Select Committee on Intelligence report that investigated CIA
claims that its use of torture in the post-9/11 era was important in
preventing acts of terrorism largely debunked them.
What's wrong with people in this country?
No comments:
Post a Comment